The RSA uses cookies on this website. By using this website you are agreeing to our use of cookies. To find out more read our cookie policy and privacy policy. More Info

Nudge, nudge, think, think

Blog

  • Behaviour change
  • Social brain

Having started the day in Kettering talking to the trustees of Youth Music, I have just come back from the advisory board of an ESRC funded project called ‘Researching Civic Behaviour’.

The main part of the meeting was taken up by a discussion of a brilliant paper written by Gerry Stoker, Peter John and Graham Smith entitled ‘Nudge, nudge, think, think: Two strategies for changing civic behaviour’.

In the paper the authors compare deliberation (which for the purposes of a clever title they call 'think') and nudging as ways of influencing behaviour and come up with the following dimensions:

View of preferences

Nudge

Fixed

Think

Malleable

View of subjects

Nudge

Cognitive misers, users of shortcuts, prone to flawed sometimes befuddled thinking

Think

Reasonable, knowledge hungry and capable of collective reflection

Costs to the individual

Nudge

Low but repeated

Think

High but only intermittently

Unit of analysis

Nudge

Individual-focused

Think

Group-focused

Change process

Nudge

Cost-benefit led shift in choice environment

Think

Value led outline of new shared policy platform

Civic conception

Nudge

Increasing the attractiveness of positive-sum action

Think

Addressing the general interest

Role of the state

Nudge

Customise messages, expert and teacher

Think

Create new institutional spaces to support citizen-led investigation, respond to citizens

It’s fascinating stuff and regular readers of this blog won’t be surprised that I wondered whether there was a cultural theory perspective here:

• Hierarchy – rules

• Individualism – nudging

• Egalitarianism – deliberation

There’s a lot more to discuss but I’ll see if anyone out there is interested first.

Be the first to write a comment

0 Comments

Please login to post a comment or reply

Don't have an account? Click here to register.

Related articles

  • How can we give up bad habits for good?

    Ian Burbidge

    With the post-Christmas resolutions looming, when we try to address the worst of our seasonal over-indulgences, the question remains: how can we give up bad habits for good?

  • Should you be forced to relax at work?

    John Owen

    As knowledge work becomes more prevalent the influences on our work and wellbeing are poorly understood. Yet the rising levels of stress in the workplace suggest that we need actions to help us retain our wellbeing under pressure. What is the benefit of taking breaks on our wellbeing, and does the nature of the break make a difference?

  • Think you're good at multitasking? Think again

    Ian Burbidge

    We are continuously interrupted at work. What impact is this having on our ability to work productivity and well-being at work?