Aren't you being a little, y'know, Dystopian? - RSA

Aren't you being a little, y'know, Dystopian?

Blog 3 Comments

  • Social brain
  • Cognition

The Argentinian genius, Jorge Luis Borges once described Utopia as "a Greek word meaning 'there is no such place'"

Could the same thing be said for Dystopia?

There have been plenty of dystopic visions of the future, most famously Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four and Huxley's Brave New World. Huxley's vision of happiness pills and pervasive virtuality now feels closer to the truth than the 'Big Brother' of Orwell's oppressive State, but I might feel differently if I lived in Russia or China.

More recently, towards the end of his epic book, The Master and his Emissary, Iain McGilchrist presents a non-fiction account of a world he believes we are, unwittingly stumbling towards. Later this month The Social Brain Centre will be publishing a critical examination of this work as a whole, featuring a dialogue with the author and reflections from various thinkers on the strength and significance of the ideas.

The central claim is that our phenomenal experience is gradually colonised through the left hemisphere's preference for, broadly, familiar, non-living and measurable things that can be used for instrumental purposes. On this account we are gradually losing touch with what Iain calls 'sources of intuitive life', as our societies become a virtual 'hall of mirrors' in which that which is re-presented is ubiquitous, and that which is genuinely unique has less air to breathe. If you are not familiar with these ideas, you can enjoy a very pleasant introduction by watching the RSAnimate which now has over a million viewers, and please watch this space for our report later this month.

So is the world slowly becoming more dystopic? On the one hand, people like Hans Rosling, Steven Pinker, Matt Ridley help to guard us against reflex pessimism, reminding us that we have never been healthier, wealthier, less violent and more innovative respectively. On the other hand you have fears of "the destructive power of a warming planet" (Obama) in Climate Change, fears for food and water security, the ever-present threat of terrorism, terrifying public health scenarios in which we all catch a deadly and hyper-contagious bug, and, relatively benignly, the sense that worldwide financial collapse is only ever a few bad decisions away.

However, such legitimate fears are not really what is meant by dystopia, which usually involves a vision of a world that is over-organised, and too sure of itself to realise that it has gone horribly wrong, and that it may have lost something of enormous value.

Indeed, chillingly, McGilchrist suggests that in so far as the world is becoming more dystopic, many of us are likely to remain oblivious:

"If I am right, that the story of the Western world is one of increasing left hemisphere

domination, we would not expect insight to be the key note. Instead, we would expect a sort of insouciant optimism, the sleepwalker whistling a happy tune as he ambles towards the abyss."

These thoughts of dystopia were prompted by watching the astoundingly brilliant satirical series, Black Mirror for the first time, just last night, over a year after most people were raving about it. I was particularly affected by the second episode, 15 Million Merits which can still be viewed on Four on Demand.

Painting such pictures of the future should induce constructive thought and action rather than despair. Gramsci famously said we need to have pessimism of the intellect but optimism of the will, while in our forthcoming report McGilchrist calls himself a hopeful pessimist.

I felt this dystopia was a particularly good illustration of McGilchrist's view of what a world dominated by the left-hemisphere might look like. The picture is of a world almost completely dominated by screens, scores, adverts, and devoid of almost anything  natural or meaningful, in which everybody knows what they are supposed to be doing, but nobody really seems to know what is going on.

Painting such pictures of the future should induce constructive thought and action rather than despair. Gramsci famously said we need to have pessimism of the intellect but optimism of the will, while in our forthcoming report McGilchrist calls himself a hopeful pessimist.

Just as we accuse people for being 'utopian' when they are being naively optimistic about how things could be, so we should call people 'dystopian' when any of these visions of dystopia are taken too literally as predictions. The point of thinking dystopically is rather to shed light on our lives as they are currently lived, and the direction we are taking, or more to the point, the direction on which we are being taken.

Join the discussion


Please login to post a comment or reply

Don't have an account? Click here to register.

  • Interesting. Maybe dystopia isn't quite the right description for the example I'm going to draw attention to, this

    I don't actually want to recommend anyone watch it, it's anything but edifying, two episodes was quite enough for me. However I think it got to the core of our problems pretty well. It's obvious from early on that it's a sexual dystopia (or dysfunctional society. The Scottish character, Matt Mitcham is the epitome of Mr Pornos.

    Before I elaborate on that I mustn't forget the crucial point that what I describe as pornos pervades virtually everything, everyone, in the story 'good' guys and bad guys.

    The ancient Greeks had different categories of love, as it were; agape subsequently becoming most commonly identified with Christian love and eros, erotic love.
    However eros tended to have a positive, elevated connotation... And why not? Hence why I make a distinction which is basically eros gone bad, pornos.

    In the Master and his Emissary Iain interprets Max Scheler's pyramid of values according to his own theory. On the one side you have values according the LH, those predominantly of pleasure and utility, to which anything approaching higher values are cynically subordinated.

    Whereas on the RH, sexual pleasure is very much subordinated to higher values, (not parasitic on) and hence eros.

    Mr Pornos is a nasty piece of work but it's a sad fact that he's precisely the sort of guy that a lot of women are attracted to (I don't think that's an exaggeration).

    Thanks to youtube, the internet, there is a flourishing of intelligent people taking a serious look at this obvious but largely neglected, by mainstream media, phenomenon.

  • was it not Thomas More who coined the term in 'Utopia' the whole joke being, that is can never exist, hence 'no place'?

  • Great article. In my opinion dystopian fiction is just as much of a positive reflection on society as it is a negative one.

Related articles