George Osborne: new ideas and new questions - RSA

George Osborne: new ideas and new questions

Blog

Just come away from the Great Room after responding to a speech by George Osborne - you can see a short interview with him below. The Shadow Chancellor concentrated mainly on the case for new and better forms of oversight and intervention in financial markets.

My response covered three points:

I welcomed George’s interest in behavioural economics (the RSA is, after all, the leading public platform for thinkers in this area). But I suggested that once we recognise that individual short term choices don’t always add up to the best aggregate outcome the discussion about ‘nudging’ takes us into even bigger debates about the relationship between affluence, economic inequality and well-being. Although David Cameron opened up the well-being debate a few years ago, this is still challenging   territory for the Conservatives.

Second, I asked about how the Conservatives are now thinking about the role of the state. The state can be big or strong in three different ways. It can employ lots of people and provide lots of services, it can collect and redistribute a lot of money, or it can pass a lot of laws that intervene in people’s lives. Take one example: we might address the growing crisis of social care by the state expanding public provision of care, by the state taking more tax giving this to people with care needs who are free to spend how they will, or we could pass a law forcing everyone to look after their grannies. Ideological anti-statists will tend to oppose each of these forms of state power.

The Tories advocate nudge-type policies which seek to shape behaviour.  George suggested in his speech today that the Bank of England might have a general power of intervention over and above any regulation, or that the Government might break up the big banks.  It seems that the Conservatives are recognising that Government needs to be more interventionist while presumably continuing to be sceptical about the state, for example, as a mass provider. I suggested it would be interesting to hear about how today’s Conservatives conceptualise the state we need for the world we are moving into.

Third, echoing my blog yesterday, I asked how economic policy might contribute to building civic capacity; how can we better fuse enterprise and the pursuit of profit with social good and civic renewal?

George gave positive, if rather broad brush, answers to each of these questions so maybe we can get him back to the RSA again soon to elaborate further.

Be the first to write a comment

0 Comments

Please login to post a comment or reply

Don't have an account? Click here to register.

Related articles

  • Pride Month 2024: Celebrating Fellows in the LGBTQ+ community

    Deborah Ajia

    For Pride Month 2024, we're celebrating our Fellows' and collaborators' impactful work supporting LGBTQ+ communities, from providing vital resources to fighting for human rights and preserving queer history through art and education.

  • From the era of anxiety to an age of aspiration

    Andy Haldane

    Shifting to an age of aspiration requires an environment where risk is seen as an opportunity, the culture is one of optimism, and investment is everywhere. Andy Haldane, RSA CEO, suggests our Design for Life mission can turn the tide of opinion to achieve those objectives.

  • Nine famous female Fellows inspiring inclusion

    Dean Samways

    International Women’s Day 2024 invites us to imagine a world where all genders enjoy equality. Where prejudice and discrimination no longer exist. This is the world our work is helping deliver to this and future generations.