Over and out? - RSA

Over and out?


I wrote yesterday about the distinction between 'power over' and 'power to'. This distinction is relevant to the crisis which now grips Europe.

By coincidence, the point is made by two extracts from articles in this week’s LRB.

First, the philosopher and social commentator Slavoj Zizek:

Imagine a scene from a dystopian movie that depicts our society in the near future. Uniformed guards patrol half-empty downtown streets at night, on the prowl for immigrants, criminals and vagrants. Those they find are brutalised. What seems like a fanciful Hollywood image is a reality in today’s Greece. At night, black-shirted vigilantes from the Holocaust-denying neo-fascist Golden Dawn movement – which won 7 per cent of the vote in the last round of elections, and had the support, it’s said, of 50 per cent of the Athenian police – have been patrolling the streets and beating up all the immigrants they can find: Afghans, Pakistanis, Algerians. So this is how Europe is defended in the spring of 2012

Second, political scientist David Runciman reviewing Ferdinand Mount’s new book ‘The New Few, or a very British Oligarchy’ (soon to feature in an RSA event):

….globalisation is a cover story for indecision and fear. It does not drive the concentration of power and wealth according to rational measures of market forces but it sows enough confusion and uncertainty to make decisive action look like too much trouble. Politicians who suspect that they don’t know what they are doing are reluctant to do anything that might confirm it

And of the Leveson Inquirey:

The congestion of British public life, its squeezed, banal thoughtless, easy way with power, its acquiescence in its own straightened quality, its thin conception of the public good, its sense of comfort with its own limited ambitions have all been on daily display

Yesterday I said that zero-sum politics is largely about ‘power over’ battles while policy is largely about ‘power to’ problems.  This is wrong. It misses a distinction between revolutionary and reformist politics.

The former – whether its class warfare on the left or fascism in the backstreets of Athens – has a ‘power over’ message: ‘we are suffering because we are being exploited by the others, we will only stop suffering when we take power from them’. Reformists – whether of the right or left - have a ‘power to’ message; ‘with our good intentions and expertise we can adjust the world to make it better for everyone’.

This is why the political centre so often falls into the trap of well-intentioned technocratic arrogance; precisely what led to the creation of a single currency, with no exit, in the complete absence of a significant deepening of European solidarity.

The Euro crisis is a ‘power to’ crisis and as it becomes increasingly clear that the leaders of Europe cannot summon a ‘power to’ solution, the great and growing danger is that it becomes a ‘power over’ crisis.

We hear every day of economic contagion but the real worry now must be contagion from the sphere of economics to the spheres of democratic authority, social order and communal peace.      

Be the first to write a comment


Please login to post a comment or reply

Don't have an account? Click here to register.

Related articles

  • Nine famous female Fellows inspiring inclusion

    Dean Samways

    International Women’s Day 2024 invites us to imagine a world where all genders enjoy equality. Where prejudice and discrimination no longer exist. This is the world our work is helping deliver to this and future generations.

  • Fellows Festival 2024: changemaking for the future

    Mike Thatcher

    The 2024 Fellows Festival was the biggest and boldest so far, with a diverse range of high-profile speakers offering remarkable stories of courageous acts to make the world a better place.

  • Inspired by nature

    Rebecca Ford Alessandra Tombazzi Penny Hay

    Our Playful green planet team summarises a ‘lunch and learn’ at RSA House that focused on how the influence of nature can benefit a child’s development.